近 7 天 · 通用任务助手

OpenClaw

委托任务、调研与成果交付

体感分50.7/10049 条评论
来源 Reddit

大家怎么看

近 7 天的 49 条评论中,评价褒贬并存。批评最集中在「稳定性」(9/19 条负面摘录)。有用户升级OpenClaw过程顺利,所有cron任务都成功保留。有用户花了两天试图从9.4升级到9.6,多次触及限制,感到厌倦。

每日体验趋势

40506047.409-2509-2709-2809-3010-01按评论日期汇总 · UTC · 每日满 5 条显示分数

用户反馈

14 条评价摘录

正面稳定性

刚完成了升级。没问题,我所有的cron jobs都迁移过来了。 干得好,开发团队!谢谢你们

机器翻译
展开原文

Just implemented the upgrade. No problems, all of my cron jobs carried over. Great job dev team! Thank you

褒贬并存稳定性

如果走那条路,有一点需要注意:Claude Code自带基于文件的记忆(在~/.claude/projects/...下),它会建议将内容保存在那里,靠近OpenClaw的memory/文件夹。请尽早决定哪个是规范的,否则事实会分散在两个地方,两个地方都不完整。

机器翻译
展开原文

One thing to watch if you go that way: Claude Code brings its own file-based memory (under ~/.claude/projects/...) and will offer to save things there, next to OpenClaw's memory/ folder. Decide early which one is canonical, otherwise facts end up split across two places and neither is complete.

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

你可能根本不需要迁移。OpenClaw可以将Claude Code作为其后端运行(claude-cli运行时),这就是我运行的设置:Telegram保持不变,工作区文件(AGENTS.md、SOUL.md、USER.md、MEMORY.md)仍然被注入到系统提示中,所以你的规则继续适用。

机器翻译
展开原文

You might not need to migrate at all. OpenClaw can run Claude Code as its backend (the claude-cli runtime), and that's the setup I run on: Telegram stays, and the workspace files (AGENTS.md, SOUL.md, USER.md, MEMORY.md) still get injected into the system prompt, so your rules keep applying.

负面稳定性

不会因为膨胀而在一天或一周后突然忘记什么,效率非常高。

机器翻译
展开原文

No forgetting a day or week later suddenly due to bloat, it is just very efficient.

负面稳定性

只是我早期用OpenClaw时它每天都在坏,但我不指望Muse也会这样

机器翻译
展开原文

Its just I used OpenClaw early on when it constantly broke every day but I'm not expecting that from muse

查看评论上下文
评论者的原帖 ↗

Muse可能由OpenClaw驱动,但没关系 我想使用Muse最好的好处是能访问模型和大量的token配额

机器翻译
展开原文

Muse is probably powered by OpenClaw but thats okay i suppose the best benefit of using muse will be access to the model and a big token allowance

正面稳定性

是的,Openclaw已经解决压缩/遗忘问题有一段时间了。只有当我需要深入专注于一个新主题时才会刷新会话。

机器翻译
展开原文

yep, Openclaw had solved the compaction/forgetting issue for a while now. I only refresh a session when I'm in need of deep focus on a new subject.

正面稳定性

QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit处理它零掉线。它遵守了两个人工关卡(批准研究简报和脚本),从晚上11:30运行到凌晨3:30。

机器翻译
展开原文

QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit handled it with zero drops. It respected two human gates (to approve the research brief and the script) and ran from 11:30 pm till 3:30 am.

褒贬并存稳定性

爪子正常运行的人很少发帖,只有出问题的人才大声嚷嚷。这不是说Openclaw是完美的。这就是为什么我们鼓励所有用户提交issue/PR来帮助我们更快地识别和修复问题。

机器翻译
展开原文

People whose claws work fine post rarely, only those who break are vocal. That's not to say that Openclaw is perfect. That's why we encourage all users to submit the issues/PRs to help us identify and fix problems quicker.

负面稳定性

我很好奇是什么让人们想用这个软件,因为我看到的帖子都是说一次更新毁掉了他们辛苦工作的一切...

机器翻译
展开原文

I'm curious about what makes ppl want to use this software when all I see are posts that an update broke everything they worked hard on...

负面稳定性

然后我会再次等待最稳定的版本

机器翻译
展开原文

And then i will wait for the most stable release again

负面稳定性

自六月以来升级真的很麻烦。试过几次,每次都得回滚。

机器翻译
展开原文

I had real trouble with upgrades since June. Tried a few times and had to roll back every time.

负面稳定性

昨晚我不得不强行完成更新。我的数据库比较大,有6GB。不知道为什么,更新过程会把数据库在内存里复制三份。我不得不把VM的内存加到24GB,然后增加swap空间才能完成更新。很奇怪的过程,但我终于搞定了。

机器翻译
展开原文

I had to force my way through the update last night. My database is fairly large at 6 GB. For some reason, the update process makes three copies of the database to ram. I had to increase the ram on my VM to 24 GB and then increase the swap for the update to be able to take place. Very odd process, but I finally got there.

负面稳定性

我有一个openclaw-ops技能,现在默认会在做任何事情之前先检查github issues,因为确实大多数时候当某些东西不工作时,我们遇到的bug已经有对应的issue存在了。

机器翻译
展开原文

I have an openclaw-ops skill that will now by default check github issues before we do anything because sure enough most of the time something doesnt work, we hit a bug for which an issue already exists.

负面稳定性工作流与集成

我不得不在其中加入心跳系统,但我比喜欢open claw更喜欢它。

机器翻译
展开原文

I've had to build a heartbeat system into them but I love it way more than open claw.

负面稳定性

9.6让我切换到了Hermes,我真希望自己早点这么做。

机器翻译
展开原文

9.6 made me switch to Hermes and I wish I'd done it sooner.