近 7 天 · 音乐与音频创作

Suno

歌曲生成与音频创作

体感分36.1/100219 条评论
来源 Reddit

大家怎么看

近 7 天的 219 条评论中,整体体验偏负面。批评最集中在「效果与质量」(21/28 条负面摘录)。好评最集中在「效果与质量」(9/13 条正面摘录)。有用户称赞Suno音质100%,但询问该项目视频和口型同步的流程细节。有用户认为Suno生成的节拍过强/分散注意力,让人难以正常聆听。

每日体验趋势

203040506038.809-2509-2709-2809-3010-01按评论日期汇总 · UTC · 每日满 5 条显示分数

用户反馈

33 条评价摘录

负面效果与质量

用它获取真正的新闻就是垃圾,但他妈的,我讨厌流行音乐如此公式化,AI现在可以随便吐出垃圾,而且它仍然很洗脑。

机器翻译
展开原文

its garbage for getting your actual news, but fuck i hate that pop music is so formulaic ai can now just puke out garbage and its still an earworm.

正面效果与质量

Suno的声音100%没问题,但他的视频和口型同步流程怎么样?

机器翻译
展开原文

Suno sound 100%, but what about his pipeline for video and lipsink?

查看评论上下文
原帖 ↗

我用Claude Code + Opus帮助构建了Astra Blue,并把昨天的AI新闻变成了一首歌和完整的音乐视频。 今天的实验:“大家能不能别发货了?” 😂 视频只用了2张参考图一次拍成,然后嵌入歌曲中。任何创意都是OPUS 5.5的决定。 歌曲由Astra GPT6创作 音乐 = Suno

机器翻译
展开原文

I used Claude Code + Opus to help build Astra Blue and turned yesterday’s AI news into a song and full music video. Today’s experiment: “Can Everybody Stop Shipping?” 😂 Video was one shot with 2 reference images only and dropped in the song. Any creativity was OPUS 5.5’s decision. Song written by Astra GPT6 Music = Suno

褒贬并存效果与质量

节拍真的很强/很干扰,根本没法听……但除此之外生成效果非常惊人。

机器翻译
展开原文

The beats are really strong/ distracting , can't really listen.. but generation is otherwise amazing.

负面效果与质量

我说的是鼓声太响、人声模糊和音量不一致这类音频问题的怪异之处,不是音乐风格和提示词那些东西。

机器翻译
展开原文

I'm talking about the drum sound too loud, vocal is muffled and the volume inconsistencies that kind of audio problem weirdness not music style and prompt stuff

负面效果与质量

V5.5是垃圾,但V6绝对拿走了大奖!有点怀念V5.5。只是对比着说说!

机器翻译
展开原文

V5.5 was trash but V6 definitely takes the price! Kind of miss V5.5. Just saying in comparison!

负面价格与额度效果与质量

我从Suno在Discord上首发就开始用了,已经生成了10万首歌,所以我知道挑出一个成功的生成结果并不能证明这个模型不垃圾。

机器翻译
展开原文

I've been using Suno since it debuted on Discord and have rolled 100k songs, so I know cherry-pickin one generation that worked don't prove this model isn't shitty.

正面效果与质量

v6与我尝试过的每种风格相比都比4.5有了巨大的提升,我不理解怎么会有人不这么认为。 你是做那种千篇一律的house音乐的吗? 四四拍俱乐部音乐? v6比4.5有创意太多了,根本没法比

机器翻译
展开原文

v6 is such a drastic improvement from 4.5 in every genre I've tried I don't understand how anyone could say otherwise. Do you make generic house music or something? 4 on the floor club music? v6 is so much more creative than 4.5 there is no comparison

负面效果与质量

是的,自定义模型,还上传我自己的音频,但variety滑块会拿我独特的提示词彻底毁掉它们,用那些陈词滥调让一切都听起来像千篇一律的Top 40背景音乐

机器翻译
展开原文

Yes custom model, and uploading my own audio, but the variety slider takes my unique prompts and totally destroys them with cliches that make everything sound like generic top 40 Musak

正面效果与质量

那个方法确实管用,谢谢。终于有一次声音值得使用了!

机器翻译
展开原文

that did work, thanks. first time sound has been worth using!

查看评论上下文
回复的评论 ↗

创建一个Sound然后使用它。我就是这样终于得到了一个Cuica鼓的。还有口弦琴。

机器翻译
展开原文

Create a Sound then use that. That's how I got a Cuica drums finally. And I got jaw harp.

负面效果与质量

关闭variety模式并不能消除我对v6的问题。 我就是讨厌v6的声音,就是这样。

机器翻译
展开原文

Turning off variety mode doesn't eliminate the problems I have with v6. I just hate how v6 sounds full stop.

负面效果与质量

而且即使关闭了variety,音频怪异问题仍然存在。

机器翻译
展开原文

and the audio weirdness still persist even with variety off.

负面价格与额度效果与质量

这玩意儿连4.5的皮毛都够不上

机器翻译
展开原文

This shit doesn’t even scratch the surface of 4.5

负面效果与质量

你无法要求 Suno 重现其音乐库中没有的乐器(其音乐库范围本来就很有限)。使用库外的乐器会导致声音再现异常。

机器翻译
展开原文

On ne peut pas demander à Suno de reproduire un instrument qui n'est pas dans sa bibliothèque (laquelle n'est d'ailleurs pas extraordinairement étendue). Sortir de cette liste expose à des bizarreries de restitution.

负面稳定性易用性编辑与控制效果与质量工作流与集成价格与额度

很多问题,它忽略歌曲中的大多数标签,乐器缺失,还有积分价格翻倍(大幅削弱),仍然出现质量下降,还不能在没有专业订阅的情况下使用V6模型,尽管有很多积分(与以前不同,另一个大幅削弱),还有那巨大的不透明

机器翻译
展开原文

many things, it ignoring most of the tags in a song, instruments missing, also double price of credits (huge nerf) and still get degradation, also can't use V6 model without pro sub despite having a lot of credits (unlike before, another huge nerf), also that big lack of clarity

负面效果与质量

Suno V.6 不再反映直到 V.5.5 为止它作为产品所能提供的东西;现在他们再来讲故事已经没用了,把钱送给一个不再有价值的产品。

机器翻译
展开原文

Suno V.6 non rispecchia più quanto sino alla V.5.5 era riuscito a dare come prodotto, ormai è inutile che vengano a raccontare delle favole e quindi regalare denaro proprio ad un prodotto non più valido.

负面效果与质量

如果他们不做出改变(我对此持怀疑态度,因为它之前是在非法数据上运行的),他们用来训练的新受限数据会导致非常糟糕的结果。清晰简单的提示词完全被忽略,所有内容听起来都一样。如果我生成50首歌,都是同一个想法反复出现,变化非常少。

机器翻译
展开原文

If they don't change something (which I doubt, since it was running on illegal data), the new restricted data they train on leads to really bad results. Clear and easy prompts get ignored completely and everything sounds the same. If I do 50 songs, it is the same idea over and over with very little variation.

正面效果与质量

这里真正起作用的是AI在为创意服务,而不是取代它。它让人更容易在情感层面上与音乐和角色产生连接。

机器翻译
展开原文

What works here is that AI is serving the creative idea, not replacing it. It makes it so much easier to connect with both the music and the characters on an emotional level.

负面效果与质量

我的目标是投诉让 Suno 看到并尝试改进。因为它真的很糟糕。

机器翻译
展开原文

My goal is to complain so Suno sees it and tries to improve. Because it's really bad.

负面效果与质量

从第一天起,v6 就明显更差了。

机器翻译
展开原文

From Day 1 v6 was noticeably worse.

查看评论上下文
原帖 ↗

我捕捉了原版封面中基本相同的时刻2024年10月5日(使用V5.0或V5.5制作),并将其与V6重制版2024年10月5日 V6重制版进行了比较(增强模式设为Normal,因为其他选项简直无法入耳)。

机器翻译
展开原文

I captured essentially the exact same moment in the original cover of October 5th 2024 (made with V5.0 or V5.5) and compared it to a V6 remaster October 5th 2024 V6 Remaster (Boost at Normal, as the other options were simply unlistenable).

原帖 ↗

根据我的判断,我可以明确确定V6是倒退。

机器翻译
展开原文

According to my ears, I can clearly determine V6 is a regression.

正面效果与质量

嘻哈 boom-bap 风格的曲目在 v6 上听起来非常棒…… 说真的。

机器翻译
展开原文

Hip-hop boom-bap tracks sounds greatly on v6... For real.

负面价格与额度效果与质量

你知道吗,但我真不敢相信你竟然认为那个你每月花30美元做出来的东西听起来比几秒钟就能免费做出来的要差得多么,它竟然算是个真正的DAW。

机器翻译
展开原文

You know that, But I cannot believe that you actually think that little toy you pay $30mo to make yourself something that sounds so incredibly worse than what can be made in just seconds for free is an actual DAW.

正面效果与质量

所以我在生成的提示词末尾加了韦斯利·斯奈普斯,结果它生成了两首歌,然后我点击了随机播放按钮,它会清理你的提示词,但韦斯利·斯奈普斯还在里面,又生成了两首,你猜怎么着,这四首全比我正在评判的那些要好。

机器翻译
展开原文

So I just added Wesley Snipes to the very end of the prompt generated it got two songs then I hit the shuffle button that cleans up your prompts using the Wesley Snipes still in there got two more and wouldn't you know all four of them were better than the ones I was judging.

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

事情变得有趣的地方就在这里。我当时在制作自己的一首真实歌曲,有几个版本我在尝试评分,因为它们都很棒,各有我喜欢的部分。

机器翻译
展开原文

This is where things get interesting. I was working on an actual song of mine and I had a few versions of it I was trying to score because they are all very good and had things that I liked.

正面效果与质量

我用Suno把它变成我可以听的歌曲。能听到自己的文字以歌曲的形式呈现。我把一些发布到YouTube上,甚至还做了几个视频。这些视频是通过AI制作的,说实话烂得可笑。但不管视频有多烂,制作它们还是有点有趣的。不过音乐才是主要部分,那是我自己的歌词。我在Suno上花了很多时间和很多积分来尝试生成完美的歌曲。

机器翻译
展开原文

I use Suno to turn it into songs I can listen to. Being able to hear my own words in a song. I post some to YouTube, and have even made a couple videos. The videos are made through ai and are honestly laughably bad. But it’s kind of fun making the videos regardless of how bad they are. The music is the main part though, it’s my own lyrics. And I spend many hours, and many credits on Suno trying to generate the perfect song.

正面效果与质量

说唱效果很好啊,不知道大家在抱怨什么,呜呜呜呜,以前你根本做不了音乐,现在给了你不需任何真正技术就能做的特权,人们还在抱怨,我们变成了多么傲慢的种族啊 🫪

机器翻译
展开原文

It works great for rap, idk what everyone is crying about, wah fucking wah, you could never make music before, now given the privelidge to be able without any real skill, yet people are still complaining, what a arrogant race have we turned into 🫪

正面效果与质量

尽管如此,我用Suno创作的音乐——对我来说——比今天电台里的大部分垃圾要好得多。

机器翻译
展开原文

Despite this the music I create with Suno - to me - is way better than most of the cr@p in the radio today.

负面效果与质量

一旦任何AI评论者听到那合成光泽和AI痕迹,他们就会把它当作劣质内容一笔勾销。旋律和歌词花了二十年创作又怎样,软件只会把你的意图扁平化成统计学上的平均值。

机器翻译
展开原文

The second anyone ai critical hears the synthetic sheen and AI artifacts, they’ll write it off as slop. It won't matter that the melodies and lyrics took twenty years to write, the software just flattens your intent into a statistical average.

褒贬并存效果与质量

如果我听V6 Suno Labs新流派转盘上的示例,其中大多数听起来确实很不错。问题是为什么我们的歌曲出来要差得多(并不总是这样,这才是奇怪的地方)。这让我觉得那些Lab示例是经过微调的,并不是尤其是付费客户期望在使用专业模型时听到的真实输出。

机器翻译
展开原文

If i listen example the V6 Suno Labs new genre wheel samples where most of them sound really good. Question is why our songs turn out much worse (not always thats the strange part). Makes me think those Lab examples are fine tuned and not realistic output what especially paying customers excpect to hear using pro model.

负面效果与质量

Suno还没有发布过一个不仅仅是演示工具可以复现的模型。

机器翻译
展开原文

Suno is yet to release a model that’s not just a demo tool to be reproduced.

负面效果与质量

我退了pro,在我看来v5好太多了。真难过

机器翻译
展开原文

I refunded my pro , v5 was so much better in my opinion. Sad

褒贬并存效果与质量

再说一遍,我仍然相信V6比之前的引擎好得多,但也仍然同意如果你不先刺激它一下,它的创造力就很有限。

机器翻译
展开原文

Again, I'm convinced that V6 is still a much better engine then the former ones, but still agree it's limited in it's creativity if you don't kick it in the balls first.

负面效果与质量

也许 Suno 不是做金属乐的最佳选择,但还有其他选择!

机器翻译
展开原文

Maybe Suno isn't the best for Metal, but there are other options!

负面效果与质量

我来这里是想找答案,为什么我的金属乐歌曲在 v6 上现在这么垃圾。我看到我不是一个人。我有早在 v3.5 时代的好歌,以及中间每个版本保存的声音,在 v6 上听起来都很垃圾。

机器翻译
展开原文

I came here to search for answers to why my metals song are so trash now with v6. I see I'm not alone. I have good songs way back from v3.5 and saved voices on each version in between that sound trash on v6.

负面效果与质量

我用全部 6 个模型试过的每一种风格都是垃圾。5.5 给我做出了我至今仍在听的不可思议的歌曲。每次我试着用 6 去做点什么,它都毫无生气、浑浊不清,听起来就像 AI 做出来的。

机器翻译
展开原文

Every single genre I’ve tried with all the 6 models is garbage. 5.5 made me incredible songs I still listen to. Every session I try to go in and make something with 6 it’s lifeless, muddy, and sounds like AI made it.