近 7 天 · 通用任务助手

OpenClaw

委托任务、调研与成果交付

体感分50.7/10049 条评论
来源 全部

大家怎么看

近 7 天的 49 条评论中,评价褒贬并存。批评最集中在「稳定性」(9/19 条负面摘录)。有用户升级OpenClaw过程顺利,所有cron任务都成功保留。有用户花了两天试图从9.4升级到9.6,多次触及限制,感到厌倦。

每日体验趋势

40506047.409-2509-2709-2809-3010-01按评论日期汇总 · UTC · 每日满 5 条显示分数

用户反馈

28 条评价摘录

正面易用性

没有问题,我所有的cron jobs都迁移过来了。

机器翻译
展开原文

No problems, all of my cron jobs carried over.

正面稳定性

刚完成了升级。没问题,我所有的cron jobs都迁移过来了。 干得好,开发团队!谢谢你们

机器翻译
展开原文

Just implemented the upgrade. No problems, all of my cron jobs carried over. Great job dev team! Thank you

正面编辑与控制

这也是我对下面"Claude忽略代理指令"评论的回答:在这个设置中它会遵循它们。

机器翻译
展开原文

That's also my answer to the "Claude ignores the agent instructions" comment further down: in this setup it follows them.

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

OpenClaw可以将Claude Code作为其后端运行(claude-cli运行时),这就是我的配置:Telegram保持运行,工作区文件(AGENTS.md、SOUL.md、USER.md、MEMORY.md)仍然会被注入到系统提示词中,所以你的规则继续适用。

机器翻译
展开原文

OpenClaw can run Claude Code as its backend (the claude-cli runtime), and that's the setup I run on: Telegram stays, and the workspace files (AGENTS.md, SOUL.md, USER.md, MEMORY.md) still get injected into the system prompt, so your rules keep applying.

正面工作流与集成

OpenClaw可以将Claude Code作为其后端运行(claude-cli运行时),这就是我的配置:Telegram保持运行,工作区文件(AGENTS.md、SOUL.md、USER.md、MEMORY.md)仍然会被注入到系统提示词中,所以你的规则继续适用。

机器翻译
展开原文

OpenClaw can run Claude Code as its backend (the claude-cli runtime), and that's the setup I run on: Telegram stays, and the workspace files (AGENTS.md, SOUL.md, USER.md, MEMORY.md) still get injected into the system prompt, so your rules keep applying.

正面安全与权限

这就是为什么 openclaw 仍然更胜一筹

机器翻译
展开原文

That's why openclaw still wins

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

你真的想把所有私人或商业数据放在云端的前沿模型上吗?

机器翻译
展开原文

Do you really want all your private personal or business data in the cloud on a Frontier model?

正面效果与质量

Open Claw做我的数字营销相关工作简直好得离谱。Open Claw + Claude Opus

机器翻译
展开原文

Open Claw is just insanely good for doing my digital marketing related work. Open Claw + Claude Opus

正面编辑与控制

我喜欢的一点是,自主性受到预算、角色分离、检查点和恢复规则的限制,而不是简单地"让代理继续运行"。

机器翻译
展开原文

The part I like is that autonomy is bounded by budget, role separation, checkpoints, and recovery rules instead of just “let the agent keep going.”

正面工作流与集成

我在新SIM卡上设置了WhatsApp,然后把这个号码分配给OpenClaw。扔掉SIM卡后它仍然能用…

机器翻译
展开原文

I just set up WhatsApp on a new sim and then assigned that number to OpenClaw. Discarded the sim and it still works…

正面编辑与控制

不,用OpenClaw和Hermes我能做很多事情,而且一切都在我的掌控之中

机器翻译
展开原文

Nop, I can do a lot of things with OpenClaw and Hermes and I control everything

查看评论上下文
原帖 ↗

Openclaw是否已经被ChatGPT关于dots的发布抹杀了? Openclaw的未来会是什么样子?

机器翻译
展开原文

Has Openclaw just been wiped out by the announcement from chatGPT regarding dots? What does the future of Openclaw look like now?

正面编辑与控制

它完全可以。

机器翻译
展开原文

It 100% can.

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

这肯定是我第1000次看到有人说Claude订阅不能用于OC了。

机器翻译
展开原文

This has to be the 1000th time I've seen someone say Claude sub can't be used with OC.

正面编辑与控制

点意味着你被锁定在openai。 openclaw仍然存在于你的环境中,你的持久化。openai的点需要它的应用程序、连接器等。openclaw让你能够构建所有这些。 数字主权仍然是openclaw的一个特性,但差异确实在缩小。 另外,你拥有你的代理文件。openai可以随时决定削弱你和它可以做的/允许的任务,而你无法控制。

机器翻译
展开原文

dots means you're locked into openai. openclaw still lives in your environment, your persistence. openai dots would need its apps, it's connectors, etc. openclaw let's you build all that. digital sovereignty is still a feature of openclaw, but the difference is definitely dwindling. also, you own your agent files. openai can decide at any point to nerf you and the tasks it can do/allows and you have no control.

正面价格与额度

任何兼容OpenAI的东西都可以通过自定义base URL接入,所以真正的选择是按token计费还是包月套餐,如果目标是不用盯着钱包看,包月是结构性的解决方案:一口价,无需按token算账。

机器翻译
展开原文

Anything OpenAI-compatible drops in via a custom base URL, so the real choice is metered tokens vs a flat plan, and if the goal is not watching the wallet, flat is the structural fix: one price, no per-token math.

正面易用性

是的,订阅可以和OpenClaw一起使用。

机器翻译
展开原文

Yes, subscriptions work with OpenClaw.

正面工作流与集成

是真的,只需安装/更新并登录claude cli,然后运行openclaw configure并选择anthropic cli

机器翻译
展开原文

it is true just install/update and login to the claude cli and then run openclaw configure and choose anthropic cli

查看评论上下文
回复的评论 ↗

我真的希望这是真的。我想用20欧元的订阅试试,哪怕只是为了运行几次Opus 5.5来修复一些问题。

机器翻译
展开原文

I really hope this is true. I want to try with a 20 euro subscription even just to get a couple of runs of Opus 5.5 to bug fix some things. 

正面稳定性

是的,Openclaw已经解决压缩/遗忘问题有一段时间了。只有当我需要深入专注于一个新主题时才会刷新会话。

机器翻译
展开原文

yep, Openclaw had solved the compaction/forgetting issue for a while now. I only refresh a session when I'm in need of deep focus on a new subject.

正面编辑与控制

Muse很酷,但供应商/生态系统锁定问题很严重。Openclaw可以采用Meta实现的最佳想法并复制它们。

机器翻译
展开原文

Muse is cool, but the vendor/ecosystem lock-in is serious. Openclaw can take the best ideas Meta implements and replicate them.

正面编辑与控制

有些东西是公司永远不会尝试/允许的,而像openclaw这样的测试工具可以让你自由实验。

机器翻译
展开原文

There are some things that companies would never try/allow that harnesses like openclaw give you the freedom to experiment with.

正面工作流与集成

使用两次重放。第一次冻结工具结果和状态,然后只重运行模型。接下来冻结模型决策并重放测试工具。第一次比较隔离决策差异;第二次暴露传输、权限和检查点bug。

机器翻译
展开原文

Use two replays. First freeze tool results and state, then rerun only the model. Next freeze the model decisions and replay the harness. The first comparison isolates decision variance; the second exposes transport, permission and checkpoint bugs.

正面工作流与集成

它遵守了两个人工关卡(批准研究概要和脚本),并从晚上11:30运行到凌晨3:30。

机器翻译
展开原文

It respected two human gates (to approve the research brief and the script) and ran from 11:30 pm till 3:30 am.

查看评论上下文
评论者补充 ↗

第一个,也是我用来测试的,是一个多智能体(6个)、多频道的YouTube制作流。我构建它是为了学习如何构建编排模型。我为每个YouTube频道创建一个知识库,使用相同的智能体结构,我可以用相同的提示为任何频道创建视频,只需要调用频道名称。流程大约运行四个小时,生成一份研究简报、一个视频脚本、十个B-roll视频、一打图片和一个投放时间线。主数字虚拟人/旁白目前发送到HeyGen生成(但正在通过添加一台专用PC将其引入ComfyUI)。 这个工作流大约需要4小时运行。QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit处理它零掉线。

机器翻译
展开原文

The first, and the one that I ran this on as my test, is a multi-agent (6), multi-channel YouTube production stream. I built it to learn how to build an orchestration model. I create a knowledge base for each YouTube channel, and using the same agent structure I can create a video for any channel with the same prompt, just invoking the name of the channel. The process runs about four hours and generates a research brief, a video script, ten b-roll videos, a dozen images, and a placement timeline. The main digital avatar/narrator is sent to HeyGen to produce for now (but is being brought into ComfyUI by adding a PC for this specific task). This workflow takes about 4 hours to run. QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit handled it with zero drops.

正面稳定性

QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit处理它零掉线。它遵守了两个人工关卡(批准研究简报和脚本),从晚上11:30运行到凌晨3:30。

机器翻译
展开原文

QWEN3.6-27B MLX-8bit handled it with zero drops. It respected two human gates (to approve the research brief and the script) and ran from 11:30 pm till 3:30 am.

正面价格与额度

用tailscale出口连接到chromebook,再连接到verizon fios出口,这是最划算的

机器翻译
展开原文

it’s the most cost effective with a tailscale egress to chromebook connected verizon fios egress

正面效果与质量

完全正确,爱死了我的claw。我当前使用的是OpenClaw version 2026.4.2 (build d74a122)。

机器翻译
展开原文

exaclty love my claw i am on You are currently on OpenClaw version 2026.4.2 (build d74a122).

正面工作流与集成

如果我有问题,我就用claude code或codex cli来修复open claw上的问题。

机器翻译
展开原文

if i have an issue i just claude code or codex cli to fix the the problem on open claw.

正面价格与额度

我看到他们把Luna 6的成本相比5.6砍了一半。太棒了

机器翻译
展开原文

I saw they cut Luna 6 costs in half compared to 5.6. it's so great

正面工作流与集成速度

Telegram/discord延迟时间大幅减少,更容易管理cron任务,手机app链接,消息撤回。

机器翻译
展开原文

Telegram/discord delay time is drastically reduced, easier to manage cron, phone app linking, revert message.

查看评论上下文
回复的评论 ↗

这样巨大的飞跃中,你注意到了什么变化?

机器翻译
展开原文

What are the changes you’ve noticed with that drastic of a jump?

评论者先前的回复 ↗

我刚全新安装了9.5版本(我上一个版本是4.26)。9.5相比4.26太好了

机器翻译
展开原文

I just did fresh install the 9.5 version (my last version is 4.26). 9.5 is so good compared to 4.26

正面工作流与集成

我也试过hermes,效果不错,但我在OpenClaw上花了很多时间定制各种功能,其他的我试过都没有它好用。

机器翻译
展开原文

I have also tried hermes and it works pretty well, but I have a lot of time into OpenClaw customizing it for various functions and nothing else I've tried works as well.

正面易用性

OpenClaw更加开放和易于使用。

机器翻译
展开原文

OpenClaw is more open and easy going on.

正面价格与额度

切换时我的每周使用量只剩下不到5%。我同时使用所有三个代理完成的任务量让我惊讶不已,而且至今还没有用完用量。

机器翻译
展开原文

I had less than 5% of my weekly usage left when I made the switch. It blew me away how much I was able to get done, using all three agents at the same time, and still haven’t exhausted the usage.